Here are knockers indeed! [post 1 of the Cuchlann fanservice series]

If a man were porter of Hell Gate…

Fanservice!  We all know it, we all, ah, have a strong opinion about it.  Is it good, is it bad?  Is it neutral?  Can we even say that about something so polarizing?

[note: I wrote this back in July. My semester continues terrible, and I should really be reading theory, Dickinson, and James Hogg right now.  But I've decided to post this, which is really unfinished.  I wanted to make this a post of three sections, examining a show in each.  As it is, it works as the beginning of a mini-series, and hopefully once the break arrives I can write parts two and three.]

I once had a professor tell us never to think of scenes such as the porter scene in Macbeth as “comic relief.”  The term implies that there’s nothing else going on in the scene, and in Shakespeare, at least, the “comic relief” scenes can tell us the most about the themes of the play, if we pay attention.  You might also classify the gravedigger scene in Hamlet as the same sort of thing.

[Here's a link directly to the Porter scene, which is Act II, scene 3 of Macbeth].  What happens in the scene is that in the latest stretches of the night, someone knocks on the door to Macbeth’s castle — this is the same night Macbeth kills Duncan, his king.  The drunken porter shambles out of his room and takes his sweet time answering the door, talking about what it would be like to be the door-warden of Hell (if you’re up on your Milton, you’ll recall that would be either Sin or Death).  It’s a hilarious scene, especially when well-played.  I tried my hand at it once, for my last Shakespeare class (the third thus far), when a friend asked me to.  I saw a performance where the actor came out into the crowd and picked on likely members, choosing my friend Brooke (who was busily knitting as she watched) to fill in for the imaginary English tailor who stole “out of a French hose.”  He begs Macduff, the man who vanquishes Macbeth, to “remember the porter,” and Shakespeareans do indeed.  The list of professions he rants about is infamous, including the “equivacators,” who were likely Jesuits.  Juxtaposed with the great sin of the play, the murder of Duncan, this scene illustrates how minor sins are welcomed into Hell just as much as major sins — providing a wealth of interpretative data:  is Macbeth’s crime greater?  Or is it just the same, and not to be worried about?  Does Macbeth fall because of his crime or because he never gets over it?

Well, you see what I mean.  I told you that to tell you this:  fanservice can work the same way, and incurs the same risks.

What I mean by “risk” is that fanservice is often considered as separate from the rest of the show (or comic) we find it in.  The general problem with a lot of readings online is that a lot of time is spent on whether or not something is “good,” which often becomes an argument about whether or not certain elements should be in the show.  The reason that’s a problem is that the element is in the show — it’s a little too late to jump in front of that problem.  More useful is the approach of asking why something is there:  what it does and how it does it?  So, with your indulgence, I’ll use a handful of examples and take a crack at what the fanservice adds to the show.

Crest/Banner of the Stars

I’m starting with Crest of the Stars because fanservice isn’t usually what springs to mind when we think of it.  But, oh, the fanservice is there, and we couldn’t be happier.  Over on my post about Baron Febdash, Kadian makes the point that the dinner memorial “mostly consisted of long pans of the Admiral’s and Lafiel’s lips, legs, and cleavage” while mentioning it was a favorite scene — which would imply it isn’t any longer?  (Incidentally, replying to Kadian, Ghostlightning makes the “comic relief” argument, claiming the fanservice is a way to break up the data-heavy dialogue for easier consumption)

Let’s look at that scene first, then.


So…  yes.  There’s a whole lot of fanservice going on.  I didn’t get any shots of Lafiel, because I didn’t spot any moments when the camera just stops to focus on her breasts or something.  I did opt not to get a screenshot of Commander Atosuryua’s leg fanservice, as I’m not convinced they would show up in a screenshot from my copy of the episode.

Anyway.  If we go by the binary I’ve described already, this scene gets thrown right out:  it has fanservice in it, and thus, has no other content.  Of course, I don’t believe that, so what else could the fanservice be doing?  Again, let’s assume it’s there on purpose.  If you’ve watched Banner of the Stars, it’s very easy to do so; the camera shots are carefully composed throughout the series.

So what’s the scene about?  It’s the memorial dinner for Baron Febdash, and the only people in calling distance who can help Atosuryua (Klowal Febdash’s sister) celebrate it also happen to be the people responsible for his death.  In true Abh fashion Atosuryua doesn’t worry about it, as it was Klowal’s fault.  They go to a fancy restaurant and discuss Klowal.

That’s the summary.  What’s really happening here?  Banner of the Stars begins with Lafiel taking command of her own ship, and the struggle she goes through in trying to command them well.  So BotS, moreso than CotS before it, is about life and death.  War, in short.  The dinner memorial comes in between the two major battle arcs of the series — this scene is in episode six of a thirteen episode series.  The placement is important, as a memorial for the dead falls in the center of a story about trying to keep people alive.  Jinto and Lafiel call back to the memorial near the end of the series, when danger strikes the ship.

We also see the “human” side of Klowal, as well as some of Atosuryua’s as well.  There’s a running thread of birth to contrast the death that starts the memorial; Jinto jokes about Abh evolutionary practices, only to be corrected:  the Abh did not evolve, they adapted.  That is, they weren’t the product of the typical system that springs from birth, but from scientific alteration to suit an environment (known in SF circles as “autoplastic adaptation”).  The birth strains back the family ties vibe underrunning the scene.

The conversation also serves to make “human” the figure that, until this point, has been a rank and a vague threat:  Commander Atosuryua.  Before this, we know two things about her:  she is Lafiel’s commander and the sister of the person Lafiel killed.  In turn, we learn a little more about Lafiel and Jinto as well.  The dinner works all around to humanize these figures.

And then there’s the fanservice.  Except not really.  It serves to underline each of these themes.  Life and death is fairly obvious, and so is birth:  the fanservice adds a sexual dimension, and there are three things that define the living:  a fear of death, a need to eat, and a need to copulate.  Add in a need for shelter and you have all the spurs behind life (it’s interesting to not that ultimately the show does include shelter, showing us that Jinto identifies the Basroil, not his home planet, as his home).  The sexual dimension of this scene underscores the desire for life that these people feel.  We’re used to seeing all three of them as relatively staid.  Most of this show we see them in uniforms, and the other outfits they sport (like Jinto’s “nobleman” duds) serve to highlight their societal placement rather than their biological needs (that is, their sexual identities).  It’s significant that this blast of fanservice happens during a meal:  two reining desires are coupled here, healthily and without issue.  Not only does this underscore what the entire series is about:  illustrating warfare as something performed by people; the alien as human; and the personal lives of these developed characters, it also shows us these two women, generally so controlled, still behaving in a controlled manner while enjoying their sexual sides in a familiar way:  wearing nice clothing that reveals them to observers.

The empty chair is Klowal’s, and the conversation centers on him, humanizing him further; we already saw his sexual side in his choice of servants and his mad Gothic desire to rape Lafiel.


Ekuryua’s insertion into the scene is then easily explained, where some feel it’s random.  She’s interested in Jinto, and Jinto clearly notices that and, while remaining devoted to Lafiel, realizes how attractive Ekuryua is.  Jinto can’t wear super-revealing clothing, it’s not typical, either in the Abh culture or ours (especially in male evening wear).  But we can see the figure of the person who he has noticed sexually more obviously than he has Lafiel.  She’s also tied in through her care for Diaho, which is the reason she’s in the shower to begin with.  Caring for Jinto’s cat is her way of getting closer to Jinto himself, and while she isn’t doing any crazy bestiality with the cat, he does serve as a surrogate for Jinto — so the scene also illustrates Ekuryua’s sexuality as well, through a steamy shower scene with a surrogate for Jinto.  The cat does run off, too, probably showing the frustration this is going to leave her in (we already know by this time Jinto’s sticking with Lafiel.

Further Reading:

Owen tackles the way people write off shows for having fanservice, assuming it inherently makes X show “bad” over here: ["Fanservice and the Blinder Effect. . ."]

Leave a comment

11 Comments

  1. You’re a sneaky bastard, with your apologetics for the sneaky bastards that pepper C/BotS with all this service.

    That’s all I wanted to say, but here’s some discussion fanservice that we like to indulge ourselves in. Alright, you did a good job here in establishing the utility of Eksuryua’s scenes in particular. It DID feel completely arbitrary to me and I suppose it does work even as merely breakers of dialogue/monologue dumps.

    I didn’t think C/BotS suffered necessarily for these distractions — if one is to relate to them as distractions, but I didn’t think they were that necessary either.

    But looking further, I realize that my Catholic socialization is driving the ship. The apparent objections I make are particularly towards sexual fanservice: corruption of the body/spirit/mind etc. and everything Augustine said. I thought of alternatives to lingering shots of abh body parts and came up with spacecraft, lander world planetscapes, abh cityscapes.

    While I stand by these alternatives, I realize that they aren’t necessarily ‘better’ or more ‘tasteful’ than Atosurya’s bosoms. Consider that my alternatives can be routinely called tech porn and scenery porn. Some people intellectually fap, and even consider this superior to actual fapping with one’s genitalia, and consider themselves better for it. I know I indulge myself with this though nowhere as often (nor as pleasurable) as looking at Lafiel in her evening gown.

    Recently, I got bothered by the nature of fanservice in a fall anime Letter Bee, to the point that its charms didn’t seem so charming anymore and I felt that the fanservice didn’t compel me to keep at it and in fact took away from the experience. I was blogging the show and now I’ve dropped it after 5 episodes.

    What bothered me about it I realize is that I was seeing children being sexualized and the show was being clever about it. I didn’t appreciate this. I suppose I don’t think badly of C/BotS because it does a very good job of making the characters seem adult. Their concerns are adult and their challenges demand maturity. Their character designs are youthful, but not child-like.

    I don’t intend to be righteous about this at all, however strongly I feel. Ultimately, I want to acknowledge that fanservice is a matter of taste and along with appropriateness it is ultimately arbitrary.

    Reply
  2. kadian1364

     /  16 November 2009

    That comment from way back was not exactly convey what I meant it to imply. That is, it’s still one of my favorite scenes from BotS because of how it humanizes the Baron, a former villain of the classic womanizer and nutcase breed, and add new layers of bonds between the characters. I especially remember Jinto’s remark about how he wouldn’t want others to attend his memorial “out of duty” and Lafiel’s reply. I wanted to say it was interesting that my sis saw the same scene and her a initial reaction was completely different (“Ick, fanservice”).

    CotS great strength is the scene composition, as you said making every shot with purpose behind it. Cheesecake scenes of Ekuryua aren’t just for the sake of pure fanservice, and CotS never relies on it, so I, and probably many others, consciously/unconsciously let it get away with more because its “smarter” going about it, than simpler minded series that use fanservice like a crutch.

    Reply
  3. @ghostlightning: Did you just have an existential crisis all over the comment section? : D I definitely think you’re right in saying fanservice can be things other than T&A.

    @kadian1364: Yeah, it’s a great scene; I didn’t mean to mischaracterize you in that way, sorry. That conversation is just one of the things that led to me writing the post. I definitely think . . . of the Stars is very smart, but in the other parts I mean to write I’m going to tackle some other shows that use fanservice as well (though probably still just as “smart”). I guess the idea is to point out that it’s a technique, rather than something that automatically disqualifies a show from serious concern.

    Reply
    • LOL existential crisis. Nah I’m just coming clean with this issue — because I think anyone can go into my archives and see all sorts of inconsistency on my part. But yeah, ‘remembering love’ is a concept wholly intertwined with fanservice ^_~

      Reply
  4. Ubiquitial

     /  17 November 2009

    Wow. I thought this blog was long dead by now.

    I think the mentality is that “sex sells, but it’s not the only thing that sells”. As I see it, fanservice, in a more serious show, is a device which keeps the “less-than-intellectual”, to put it tactfully, portion of the audience engaged. Or perhaps to prod already devoted fans into buying character merchandise. Erotic Images can provoke even the best and brightest (Einstein was a bit of a playboy, from what I’ve heard).

    To sum it up, fanservice is an effective, albeit overused, tool to get the attention of viewers. However, I wouldn’t recommend looking too deep into it. Westerners tend to do that sometimes. A service scene is just a service scene, after all. And Gundam was made to sell toys. And Eva was a depressed man’s ramblings.

    But this is C/BotS… It’s probably deeper than most other animes.

    that said,

    Lafiel FTW~

    Reply
    • There’s not actually any such thing as looking too deep into a text of any sort. That’s a pejorative term for what’s more commonly known as “reading.”

      And the blog’s never been dead. Just sleeping. We’re all busy with school work.

      Reply
      • Ubiquitial

         /  17 November 2009

        “Reading” what? The perceived meanings of a work, or the intentions of the creator?

        Glad this blog is back. At least for now.

      • The constructed meanings of the author of the secondary material — that is, the blogger (in this case). Formal “reading” is always an exercise in explaining a view for an audience to consider. The intention of the creator never enters into it, unless the blogger wanted to deal with A) biography — which has no real connection to the work, or B) criticism the creator made — perhaps an essay on what SF means, in which case it’s another text to be “read” in the same way.

      • Ubiquitial

         /  18 November 2009

        I see… does make sense

  1. Mapping the Territories of Fanservice (with the Compass of Subjectivity LOL) « We Remember Love
  2. (Utena III) Players « Super Fanicom BS-X

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 369 other followers

%d bloggers like this: